Back to Newfane credit unions

Ontario Shores

PO Box 9, Newfane, NY 14108
NCUA Insured4.0 (26 reviews)1 charter

Verified Information

NCUA Insured

Member-Owned

1 charter

Established in 1961

Contact this credit union directly for detailed information about membership eligibility and current rates.

Location & Directions

Address

PO Box 9

Newfane, NY 14108

Service Area

This credit union is located in Newfane and serves members in the NY area. Currently serving 11,720 members.

Membership Info:

Contact the credit union to confirm membership eligibility requirements for your area.

Note on Membership

Credit union membership is based on a common bond. Contact this credit union directly to confirm you qualify for membership.

Financial Health

Q4 2025 · NCUA

Key indicators from NCUA regulatory filings. Tap any metric to learn what it means.

Source: NCUA Federally Insured Credit Unions list, Q4 2025.

Loan Rates

Rates sourced from NCUA call report data (Q4 2025). Contact the credit union for current rates and terms.

New Auto Loan

5.50%

Used Auto Loan

6.15%

Personal Loan

8.75%

Credit Card APR

9.90%

Important: Rates are sourced from NCUA call report filings (Q4 2025) and reflect averages reported by the credit union — not guaranteed quotes. Contact the credit union directly for current rates and terms.

Your actual rate will vary based on your credit score, loan term, and financial profile. Personal loans and credit cards tend to see the most variation.

Best Rates in NY

Lowest rates currently reported by credit unions in NY (NCUA Q4 2025).

Rates from NCUA regulatory filings. Contact credit unions directly for current rates.

Branches & Locations(5 total)

Member Reviews

4.0

26 Google reviews

Reviews sourced from Google Maps. Ratings reflect member experiences at this credit union.

View on Google Maps
k b

k b

9 months ago

They dont help with anything. They just deny you and tell you to figure it out for yourself. They get paid to just stand there pretty much. Whole family banks with them currently but won't be soon due to their lack of care and help. DONT BANK WITH THEM THEY WILL TAKE YOUR MONEY.

Joe

Joe

8 months ago

They have been giving my money to someone else for two weeks now. This place is absolutely ridiculous. No one has any clue what is going on. If there was 0 stars they would deserve it.

Wayne Michalak

Wayne Michalak

2 years ago

As a new local business owner in the area I stopped there today to purchase some rolled coins. The clerk told me that I could not do that because I was not a member and because that even members were now charged an extra fee to do that! My response? Good luck keeping members! Not one of the better Banks I've ever dealt with and probably will never deal with again

Justine Miller

Justine Miller

4 years ago

I bank here. They usually have friendly service. I really like Stacy. I would almost give 3 stars because they often don't answer the phone even with time in between calls. They also don't do the direct deposit ledger right away on Monday.

Daniel Dudek

Daniel Dudek

4 years ago

Have never had a major problem. Not sure why anyone would choose one of those other banks just to get fee'd to death or mowed down by small print disclosures. I work for a different very popular bank and let me just say there is a huge difference in products, ethics and competency.

Contact Tips

Best Time to Call

Weekdays 9am–4pm typically have the shortest wait times for new member inquiries.

What to Ask

  • • Current loan rates & terms
  • • Membership eligibility requirements
  • • Minimum deposit to open an account
  • • Online & mobile banking features

NCUA Insured

Your deposits are federally insured up to $250,000 per account category by the National Credit Union Administration (NCUA).